I've liked the Mac mini from the moment it first appeared. The new Intel-based minis are particularly exciting because they have the potential to provide something I've been looking for since early 2005 - high performance, silence and a small form factor.
The mini seems to be an ideal media center box. Both the iMac and MacBook Pro offer 2 GHz CPUs, 7200 RPM hard drives and ATI Radeon graphics. They're designed for performance. The mini trails with a 1.67 GHz CPU, a 5400 RPM drive and Intel 950 graphics. This keeps costs down, minimizes heat dissipation issues and is more than adequate for a media center machine.
I see the mini as a viable candidate for replacing my aging 2.6 GHz P4 desktop. Despite the shortcomings, the mini's CPU and hard drive can be replaced. I've been working off of my Alienware Pentium M notebook for nearly a year, and I love it - except when I'm doing two processor-intensive tasks at once. I need the ability to execute two threads simultaneously in hardware. I don't really care if it's through hyperthreading, dual cores or dual CPUs. The mini can give me this, as well as all of the other things on my wish list. I don't play games, so I'm not concerned with 3-D graphics performance. Having said that, 3-D performance on my Alienware (Intel Extreme Graphics 2) is good enough, and the mini's engine is two generations more advanced.
OK, it's clear that I like the mini for its form factor, silence and performance potential. I'd have to raise the bar a bit in order to make it a viable desktop replacement. I'd want a faster CPU and a faster hard drive. That's really about it. I'm not worried about thermal problems, since I've read about people swapping thier mini's 1.5 GHz Core Solo for a 2.0 GHz Core Duo with no negative fallout. I've also read that the thermal characteristics of 2.5" 7200 RPM drives and 5400 RPM drives are nearly identical (check out the specs on Hitachi's site). Realistically, I'd probably go with the 1.83 GHz Core Duo because it has the best price point. The 2.0s seem a bit overpriced. Apple also charges too much for RAM. I need 2 GB, and $300 feels a bit high for the upgrade. I figure that if I'd have to open the case to install everything else, snapping in two memory sticks won't be a problem.
Here's my proposed shopping list for a pimped mini (prices from apple.com and newegg.com):
We're looking at just over $1200 for a tiny, fast and silent development machine. Sadly, here's where my fantasy ends. I've found my Holy Grail, but I really can't justify the cost right now. My notebook and my P4 desktop still serve me quite well, despite their shortcomings. Plus, Spring has arrived and the cash is better spent on house-related stuff. I figure that I'll be ready to upgrade later this year, and Intel is promising the next revision of the Core Duo, so everything just may come together very nicely. I've waited for over a year, so a few more months won't kill me.
- 1.5 GHz Core Solo Mac mini 600
- SuperDrive upgrade 50
- 1GB DDR2-667 (5300) SO-DIMM (x2) 180
- 100GB 7200 RPM SATA drive 195
- 1.83 GHz Core Duo CPU 190